The Happiness Curve & The Experience MachineThis is a featured page





The Direction Of Happiness



a. Review Nozick's thought experiment using the upward and downward sloping lines in
Chapter 10.
And see my summary below.
b. Determine whether you would prefer life A or life B to be your life AND state the reasons for your preference. Focus your answer on isolationg whatimportance feature your chosen life possess that is lacking in life unchosen. Consider what conclusions/implications about the nature of happiness are suggested by your preference.


The Experience Machine

Imagine the life you would describe in c above; or, the most desireable life you can imagine living. Now imagine that life lived in The Experience Machine (chapter 10), not in reality. So, describe the emotions, thoughts and feelings you would want to have over your lifetime, and that all of them are recreated in the experience machine. Answer this question: Would you prefer life in the machine over the life that you are most likely to live in reality (as far as you can estimate)? Explain the reasons for your decision and what this implies about the nature of happiness, and the ultimate goals you set for your life. What is happiness given your position on the thought experiment?
See my summary below.

BRIEF summary of the happiness curve:
The first interesting point Nozick makes is that we care about more than the total amount of happiness in our life. This is clearly shown by considering two lives with the same amount of happiness in them, but where one (A) slopes continuously upward to increasing happiness as time goes on. The other life (B) slopes continuously downward. However, both lives have the same amount of happiness in them. Despite the equal amount of happiness, A seems like a clearly preferable life. Things are always getting better, and we live with the expectation of good things in the future. B has the added pleasures of remembering past happiness, though things continue to decline. Nozick believes that almost everyone would choose A over B if presented with such a choice. Thus, something else other than the mere amount of happiness matters to us, since that is the only basis for our preference. What is the something else? Nozick calls it the 'narrative direction' of happiness, its shapes and contours over a life. We want good experiences structured in a certain way, not just stuffed in a bucket.

BRIEF summary of the experience machine:
The Experience Machine! This is cool, and it shows something important about happiness. Suppose for the sake of argument that we had a machine which completely recreated the nature of real experiences in your mind as you float in a tank. When in the tank you completely believe your experiences are real. Moreover, you can program any range of experiences that you want to; any series of highs and lows, different values, different careers, etc. You could program the experiences to seem very real to life as well, but very positive. From the inside, your life will feel as good as possible. Would you get in for your whole life? Why not? From the inside, nothing could be missing. You can even feel like you're growing, and real and deep, and changing. Again, from the inside, nothing is missing. If you would not get in, then you must care about more than how things feel from the inside. The Experience Machine shows this clearly, although many of us assume that how things feel to you is what determines the quality of your life. Now this seems mistaken, or so Nozick argues.


arete
arete
Latest page update: made by arete , Apr 16 2009, 11:21 PM EDT (about this update About This Update arete Edited by arete

9 words added
65 words deleted

view changes

- complete history)
Keyword tags: None
More Info: links to this page
Started By Thread Subject Replies Last Post
deedsamene happiness reponse 0 Dec 18 2008, 3:47 PM EST by deedsamene
Thread started: Dec 18 2008, 3:47 PM EST  Watch
We want happiness in a certain way and at a certain time, and that is the truth for most people. To most those two scenerios dont look the same. There is something about gaining something that is considered good over time forwards, that having it and letting it go. There are different scenerios that can change ones decision but for me thats why i would pick it because your life usually starts at 0 and goes to whenever.. adding in age and happiness is the best possible scenerio for me
Do you find this valuable?    
AshleyFields Happiness 2 Dec 15 2008, 11:32 PM EST by eabedrossian
Thread started: Oct 3 2008, 4:49 AM EDT  Watch
In all honesty, I would prefer life B over A. My reasoning for choosing this life is because of many different reasons. One is because that life seems more ideal even though both life A and B have the same amount of happiness. I would rather have an unhappy beginning and work my way up to the happiness because I personally feel that if my life is that way then my appreciation for happiness will be much greater than if I was just happy from the start. But my decision depends on where life starts on the graph. In class the Professor used the example of life starting at age 18. If that was the case then I would choose life A but since I don’t know where the happiness starts I will stay with life B. another reason why I would choose life B is because right now at this moment in my real life I am experiencing life A and I feel that it would suck to have all the happiness and joy one moment then watch it slowly slip away and all you have is memories and not so much happiness anymore because that lost can be a little depressing. Life A has happiness handed to them and it was an easy thing but to slowly lose it is not such a good feeling because happiness is all life A knows and trying to adjust to the different life may not be as easy as it might be for life B. they start off in a very unhappy state of mind and in life but the transition from unhappy to the highest point of happiness in their lives may be much easier in my opinion. This whole decision varies for each individual and what happiness means to the individual choosing the life they prefer. To me happiness is anything that makes you smile and gives you a good feeling inside your mind, body and soul and I would like to end life happy and look back and appreciate the unhappy place I came from in the earlier chapters in my life. But that’s me personally.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None (edit keyword tags)
Show Last Reply
Anonymous The Direction Of Happiness 1 Dec 1 2008, 2:12 AM EST by Anonymous
 
Thread started: Nov 7 2008, 2:54 PM EST  Watch
McClure-
If I had to step into the “Experience Machine” and make a choice I think I would have to go with life A. Life A would take me from the least happy to the happiest. I have many reasons why I would pick life A. With life A you always have something to look forward to. I think if I were at my happiest in the beginning stages of life I would not have many memories of my happiness and as I grew older I would appreciate my life more. I would like my happiest times in life to be as I get older so I can enjoy them with my daughter. I would not want her to see me on a down word slop as time went on and think that is the way life should be. I would like her to experience the joy with her mother and remember me as a happy person. I would like to grow old and be happy with my husband and family. I believe that family is what really makes you happy.
Do you find this valuable?    
Keyword tags: None (edit keyword tags)
Show Last Reply

Anonymous  (Get credit for your thread)


Showing 3 of 6 threads for this page - view all