A Wetpaint Site
|
TV Fandex 100
Sign in to Wetpaint
Internet Explorer 6.0 is not supported. Please try
IE 8
or
Firefox
.
Home
Discussions
Photos
Videos
News
Updates
Droplets
Members
Sign in
or
Apply to be a Writer
Report page
Share this
The Philosophy of Suicide
Similar to many topics in philosophy, there are multiple views on the subject of suicide. I included several different view points, but I'm sure there's still a lot of information out there!
Discussion about the topic of suicide from a philosophical point of view dates back to at least the time of Plato. Socrates expresses his agreement with the thesis that suicide is always wrong because it represents the releasing of our souls from our bodies that the gods have placed us in as a form of punishment in
Phaedo
. Plato also believed the act of killing oneself is wrong, which he expressed in the Laws. Though he did define four exceptions: (1) when one's mind is morally corrupted and one's character can therefore not be salvaged (Laws IX 854a3-5), (2) when the self-killing is done by judicial order, as in the case of Socrates, (3) when the self-killing is compelled by extreme and unavoidable personal misfortune, and (4) when the self-killing results from shame at having participated in grossly unjust actions. (Laws IX 873c-d) (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/suicide/). Plato considered suicide under any other circumstances due to one's laziness and cowardliness to deal with life's difficulties. Aristotle also saw suicide as immoral and hurtful to the state, but does not detail how it is wronging the state.
On the other hand, the Stoics did not see suicide as immoral. They believed if the means of living a naturally prosperous life were unavailable, then killing oneself maybe justified. Stoics believe that a wise person realizes that if advantages, such as good physical health, are lacking, then ending one's life does not affect one's moral virtue negatively or positively.
Christian doctrine generally believes the act of killing oneself is morally wrong. St. Augustine is credited with being the first to justify the Christian prohibition of suicide. He interpreted ‘thou shall not kill’ from the fifth commandment to include the killing of oneself. St. Augustine determined that suicide was an unrepentable sin. St. Thomas Aquinas later defended this position with the following justifications: (1) Suicide is contrary to natural self-love, whose aim is to preserve us. (2) Suicide injures the community of which an individual is a part. (3) Suicide violates our duty to God because God has given us life as a gift and in taking our lives we violate His right to determine the duration of our earthly existence (Aquinas 1271, part II, Q64, A5).
In 1783 David Hume wrote an essay titled “On Suicide,” in which he argues against the Thomistic position on suicide. The main arguments of Hume’s essay are: (1) If ‘divine order’ refers to the casual laws created by God, then it would always be wrong to break these laws in order to increase our happiness, but God often lets us go against these laws when we respond to illness or injury. (2) If ‘divine order’ means the natural laws God has willed for us that were meant to produce our happiness, then why should suicide be excluded from conforming to these laws if we feel the balance of our happiness is best served by it? (3) If ‘divine order’ refers to any occurrence that God has consented to, then God must consent to all our actions since an omnipotent God can presumably intervene at any point. If God has placed us upon the Earth like a “sentinel,” then our choice to leave this post must be acceptable by God.
From (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/suicide/).
A helpful link if you're interested in reading more on the philosophical views on suicide:
http://comp.uark.edu/~mpianal/suicide.htm
http://static.wetpaint.com/img/bg/1.png?v=20091218144352
Ms.deBouvior
Latest page update:
made by
Ms.deBouvior
,
Apr 29 2008, 2:00 AM EDT
(
about this update
About This Update
A clip from the movie "The Bridge" (2006, Eric Steel), a documentary about several individuals who committed suicide by jumping off the Golden Gate Bridge.
-
Ms.deBouvior
1 widget added
view changes
-
complete history
)
Keyword tags:
philosophy
suicide
More Info:
links to this page
Share this
Threads for this page
Start a New Thread as
Reply as
Anonymous (
Get credit for your thread
)
Subject:
Please enter some text (at least 3 characters).
Message:
Please enter some text (at least 3 characters).
Quote:
Tags:
One or more of your tags have exceeded the 30 character limit.
Category:
General Discussion
General Discussion
Cancel
Posting...
Note: You can enter up to [REMCHARS] additional characters.
Did you know you can edit the content of this page by clicking EasyEdit?
Post a new thread
There are no threads for this page. Be the first to start a new thread.
Related Content
(
what's this?
Related Content
Thanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on
Wetpaint Central
.
)
Philosophy of Suicide
The Logic Of Emotion
The physics of philosophy
Philosophy
Philosophical Self Portrait
JavaScript must be enabled in order for you to contribute to this site.
To start contributing, enable JavaScript by changing your browser options, then
try again
.
Home
Current Courses
Thought Experiments & Experimental Thinking
An Examined Life
Mythology
Everything Else
Emotional Ambivalence
Fun
Philosophers
Sample Discussion Assignment
Global Warming
Ethics Debates
PhiloQuotes
Morality And Emotion
John Locke on Money
Time and Experience
Nonviolence
The Commons
Mind and Language
Sample Short Essay_Phil_1
Sexual Morality
Mother Theresa As Hero
Discussion Of Fairweather's Virtue Epistemology
SFSU_FALL_07
Ol' Blues
Intellectual Virtues For The Emotionally Confused
In The Cave Or Out Of The Cave?
Mish-Mash
Civil Disobedience
Disobedience Debates
The Invisible Hand Of Morality
Example Of Thought Experiment Paper
Ethics, Science and Technology
Existentialism
Course Study Resources
Module 1-Hum-28
Phil-1 Module 1
Nagel The Absurd
Denge Fever
Music 4 Sarah
kaplan lecture
Getting Started
Update
Nietzsche
Points Of Interest
blues
Sartre
Al-Ghazali
Marx
The Moment Of Great Change
Descartes' Dualism
Student Pages
Full
Waxing
Waning
USF 230 Pages
SFSU 101 Pages
What would you like to know
Christianity vs Catholicism
The Philosophy of Suicide
Female Philosophers
DREAM
cheesecake pie or cake
Does God Exist
Axiom of Choice
Nietzsche: The 3 Metamorphoses
Meaning of Life
Scientology 101
Oedipus Rex
River Styx
The Druids
dfg
Christianity vs Muslims
Confucious
Taoism vs Confucianism
Charles Darwin
Michel de Nostradamus
What is Existentialism
What is Tachyons
Egyptian Mythology
History of Religion
Greek Goddess
Mormonism
Famous Greek Goddess'
yoga and taichi
What are dreams, why and how do we have them?
Reality
What is Epistemology?
Jehovah's Witnesses
BURMA
Genocide in Burma
Lao Tzu
Machiavelli
Skepticism
Philosphers who arent males
Major Religion History
Thought Experiment Assignment
The Century Of The Self
Courses Open
Participation & Discussion
Philosophical Q & A
Continue Your Philosophical Education with a Major Or Minor in Philosophy
Hi
study guide
voice
Extra Credit: A Few Of Your Favorite (philosophical) Things
new page
(Uncategorized)