Hypothesis:When Mary leaves the room and her black and white world she will get a huge shock. She will also learn a lot. I expect she will be happy. There is a big difference in the sensations from a black and white versus a color world.
Set Up: When I was thinking about this I tried to come up with other examples. Things we think about then do. My idea was to compare how I felt and thought about something before I experienced it and after.
Experiment: Examples like flying in a plane, driving a car, going to college, shooting a rifle, jumping out of a helicopter. For all of these things the experience is very different from the theoretical knowledge. Therefore there must be two different kinds of knowledge. The kind that comes from experience and a kind that comes from studying theory. We learn and remember the experience kind of knowledge more easily. At least I do.
Experiment Results: We are only able to personally experience a limited amount because life is short. To learn most we must learn from other peoples experience and from studying theories as they summarize the learning and experiences of many other people. The fact that we learn something different implies that the mind and the brain do not operate with experience and theory as interchangeable. We are not made just by our experiences but they are certainly very important. More important than our theoretical learning.

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?    

Show Last Reply

*Hypothesis: My hypothesis is that if a person knows everything about a particular subject without actually experiencing that subject will they be learning anything when they actually come into contact with the subject
*Experimental Set Up: The set-up is that this scientist, Mary, knows everything there is to know about color and how and why we perceive and say it to be true, but she is has been in black and white all her life, i.e. never seeing color, the question of whether or not when she goes into the real world will color surprise or not is what we don’t know.
*Experimental Results: I think that Mary will have a cultural shock when she actually leaves the room, and experiences color for the first time. Experiencing something is so much more different than learning about it. One can only learn so much, but the second they step into the real world and see it for the first time, there is no changing that. Having only the sight of black and white while you are learning everything about color, is like a blind person learning everything about color, they are still yet to see it, so they cant truly know it until they experience it.
*Conclusion regarding initial hypothesis: Experiences change everything. So while Mary thinks she is well informed, the second she gets out of her room, she might even cry from what will hit her. Experiences help us develop as a people, and until one experiences something they can never learn from it. Having an understanding and an experience completely changes the way you look at the subject be it color, or something else in life, people grow from things that involve both and later it helps shape their identities.

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?